ADAS and Bad Weather: Why Drivers Must Turn Off These Systems to Avoid Liability
The Double-Edged Sword of ADAS
Automated Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) have transformed modern driving by reducing the risk of accidents through advanced technologies such as Lane Keep Assist (LKA), Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC), and Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB). These systems rely on sensors, cameras, and radar to help drivers maintain control, avoid collisions, and drive more safely.
However, while ADAS is designed to enhance road safety, it is not foolproof. In adverse weather conditions—such as rain, snow, ice, and fog—ADAS components can become impaired, leading to false readings, system failures, or even unintended vehicle movements. Vehicle manufacturers explicitly warn in their owner’s manuals that these systems may not function correctly in bad weather and should be disabled when necessary.
Ignoring these warnings could lead to a higher risk of accidents and potential legal liability. If a malfunctioning ADAS feature contributes to an accident, the driver may be held responsible for failing to maintain control of their vehicle. This article explores the limitations of ADAS in inclement weather, the legal implications of failing to disable these systems, and how drivers can protect themselves from liability.
How ADAS Can Malfunction in Bad Weather
ADAS features depend on cameras, radar, and sensors to detect lane markings, vehicles, pedestrians, and obstacles. When weather conditions obstruct or distort these inputs, ADAS may respond unpredictably or fail altogether. Here’s how common ADAS features can malfunction in inclement weather:
Lane Keep Assist (LKA) Can Steer You into Danger
Lane Keep Assist (LKA) helps keep a vehicle within its lane by detecting road markings and making minor steering adjustments. However, this system is only effective when lane markings are visible and properly detected by the car’s cameras.
Why LKA Fails in Bad Weather
- Heavy rain, fog, and snow can obscure lane markings, making it difficult for LKA to track the vehicle’s position.
- Ice and slush buildup on cameras can prevent the system from functioning properly.
- If the system misinterprets lane markings, it could apply incorrect steering corrections, leading to dangerous maneuvers.
- A study found that under normal conditions, LKA-equipped vehicles veered out of their lanes 17% of the time. In bad weather, this failure rate increased to nearly 70%.
⚠️ Manufacturer Warning: Subaru advises disabling Lane Keep Assist in poor weather conditions, construction zones, or when lane markings are unclear, as the system may behave unpredictably.
Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) May Fail to Detect Slowing Traffic
Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) adjusts a vehicle’s speed based on the distance to the car ahead, reducing the need for manual braking and acceleration. This feature relies on radar sensors that can be obstructed by snow, ice, and heavy rain.
Why ACC Is Unreliable in Bad Weather
- Radar sensors covered by snow or ice may not detect vehicles ahead, increasing the risk of rear-end collisions.
- In heavy rain or fog, ACC may miscalculate distances, causing it to brake too late or not at all.
- Some vehicles display a “Sensor Blocked” warning, but drivers who fail to switch to manual control remain at risk.
⚠️ Manufacturer Warning: Toyota warns that ACC may not function properly in bad weather and advises drivers to avoid using it when visibility is poor.
Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB) May Not Stop in Time
Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB) is designed to detect obstacles and apply the brakes automatically to prevent or mitigate collisions. However, this feature relies on cameras and sensors that are easily compromised in bad weather.
Why AEB Can Be Dangerous in Inclement Weather
- AEB systems struggle to detect vehicles and pedestrians when cameras are obscured by rain, fog, or snow.
- A study found that at 25 mph, AEB failed to stop in time 17% of the time under ideal conditions, and the failure rate was significantly higher in rain and snow.
- AEB may provide a false sense of security, causing drivers to react more slowly if they assume the system will brake automatically.
⚠️ Manufacturer Warning: Honda warns that AEB performance is impaired in inclement weather and should not be relied upon as a substitute for manual braking.
Why Failing to Turn Off ADAS in Bad Weather Could Lead to Civil Liability
Drivers in states like Kansas and Missouri have a legal duty to operate their vehicles safely, regardless of whether ADAS is engaged. If a malfunctioning ADAS system contributes to an accident and the driver fails to disable it despite manufacturer warnings, they could face legal consequences.
Potential Liability Risks
Negligence in Vehicle Operation
Drivers are required to maintain full control of their vehicles at all times. If a driver allows an unreliable ADAS feature to dictate steering, speed, or braking in hazardous conditions and an accident occurs, they may be found negligent.
Ignoring Manufacturer Warnings
- Owner’s manuals explicitly state that ADAS features may not function properly in bad weather.
- Failing to heed these warnings could demonstrate negligence, making the driver legally responsible for damages.
False Sense of Security
- ADAS features can create overconfidence, leading drivers to delay reactions in critical moments.
- If a driver fails to take manual control in time, they could be held responsible for preventable accidents.
How Drivers Can Protect Themselves from Liability
To reduce the risk of accidents and legal consequences, drivers should take the following precautions when driving in inclement weather:
✅ Turn Off Lane Keep Assist (LKA) When Visibility Is Poor
If lane markings are obscured by rain, snow, or fog, disable LKA to prevent unexpected steering inputs.
✅ Disable Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC) in Heavy Rain or Snow
Switch to manual driving in poor weather to ensure full control of speed and braking.
✅ Do Not Rely on Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB) in Low Visibility
Always maintain a safe following distance and be prepared to brake manually.
✅ Regularly Clean Sensors and Cameras
Before driving in bad weather, wipe down ADAS sensors to remove ice, dirt, or water droplets.
✅ Follow Manufacturer Guidelines
Review your vehicle’s owner’s manual for specific ADAS limitations and weather-related warnings.
Conclusion: Driver Responsibility Comes First
ADAS features are designed to enhance driver safety, but they cannot replace human judgment—especially in adverse weather conditions. Drivers in Kansas and Missouri have a legal duty to operate their vehicles safely, which includes turning off ADAS features when they malfunction.
If an ADAS system fails due to bad weather, the driver is still responsible for maintaining control and avoiding accidents. Ignoring manufacturer warnings and allowing ADAS to make unpredictable driving decisions could result in serious crashes, injuries, and legal liability.
If you or your loved one has been injured in a collision on ice caused by driver negligence, the skilled auto accident injury trial lawyers at Kendall Law Group are here to help you put your life back together.
📞 Call us at (816) 531-3100 for a free consultation or reach out HERE.
Additional Resources
